Mad Men and Philosophy: Nothing is as it Seems
William Irwin, James B. South, Rod Carveth
About the Author
Questions & Answers
The show "Mad Men" vividly reflects the tension between individualism and societal expectations in the 1960s. Characters like Don Draper embody the individualist spirit, seeking personal fulfillment and self-creation despite societal norms. He flouts traditional gender roles, engages in affairs, and maintains a sense of self despite his past. However, societal expectations are evident in characters like Betty Draper, who adheres to the ideal of the perfect housewife, and Roger Sterling, who embraces materialism and authority. The show also highlights the struggle of women like Peggy Olson, who seeks professional success while navigating gendered expectations. The tension is further underscored by the evolving portrayal of race and the changing dynamics of power and authority, as the show progresses.
In "Mad Men," advertising is portrayed as a powerful force in shaping human desires and societal values. Characters like Don Draper exemplify the ability of advertising to create desires, manipulating emotions and societal norms to sell products. The show suggests that advertising can create artificial needs, transforming luxury items into necessities, as seen with the Kodak Carousel campaign. It also highlights the manipulation of desires, as with Betty Draper's desire for Heineken, which was crafted by advertising. The show further explores the ethical implications of advertising, questioning the honesty and respect between advertisers and consumers, and the impact of advertising on individual authenticity and societal values. Overall, "Mad Men" portrays advertising as a significant influencer in shaping human desires and societal values, often with manipulative and sometimes harmful effects.
The characters in "Mad Men" embody existentialist themes through their actions and decisions. Don Draper's constant reinvention, from Dick Whitman to Don Draper, reflects the existentialist pursuit of authenticity and freedom. He seeks to transcend his past and create a new identity, yet his inability to fully escape his past highlights the limitations of freedom. The show also explores the search for meaning, as characters like Betty Draper and Joan Holloway grapple with societal expectations and their own desires. Their choices, often driven by fear and desire, illustrate the existentialist concept of bad faith, where individuals accept pre-determined roles rather than creating their own meaning. The characters' decisions to either conform or resist societal norms, and their struggle to find authenticity and purpose, are central to the show's exploration of existential themes.
The series "Mad Men" portrays ethical dilemmas in advertising through the use of manipulation and deception. Key issues include:
-
Consumer Agency: Advertisers manipulate consumers, undermining their autonomy and ability to make informed choices. This raises questions about the ethical treatment of consumers as rational agents.
-
Honesty and Respect: Ads often lie or omit important information, violating Kant's principle of treating others as ends in themselves, not merely means. This lack of honesty and respect can harm consumer trust and societal values.
-
Truth and Advertising: The portrayal of products as perfect or inherently beneficial, despite potential harm, challenges the concept of truth in advertising. This can lead to unrealistic expectations and dissatisfaction.
-
Social Impact: Advertising's manipulation of desires can contribute to societal issues like consumerism, materialism, and environmental degradation, raising ethical concerns about the long-term well-being of individuals and society.
-
Race and Gender: Ads often perpetuate stereotypes and discrimination, reinforcing harmful social norms and contributing to inequality.
These dilemmas highlight the need for ethical guidelines in advertising that prioritize honesty, respect, and the well-being of consumers and society.
The show "Mad Men" vividly reflects the 1960s' social and cultural issues through its portrayal of gender roles and racial dynamics. Gender roles are rigidly defined, with men as the breadwinners and women as homemakers. Women face discrimination and are confined to supporting roles, while men like Don Draper embody the ideal of the powerful, unemotional professional. The show also highlights the rise of second-wave feminism, as seen through characters like Peggy Olson, who challenges traditional expectations and works to gain independence and recognition.
Racial dynamics are similarly stark, with African Americans portrayed as subordinate and often silent, reflecting the prevalent racism of the era. The portrayal of Jews also reflects anti-Semitism, with characters like Rachel Menken facing discrimination. The show's nuanced exploration of these issues underscores the complexities and challenges of the 1960s, making it a compelling study of its time.